{
  "schema": 1,
  "status": "passed",
  "kind": "scoped-ai-assisted-review",
  "reviewed_at": "2026-11-10",
  "summary": "AI-assisted reviewers checked the exact definitions, manual witness arithmetic, source convention and bounded checker behavior. The programs were rerun: all 8 primary and 31 separate-implementation tests passed, with the recorded outputs matching exactly.",
  "reviewed_files": {
    "README.md": "266a874f391588b6d27e481a9df43ed2c65b65d306e3a21c40033dcb76437eb0",
    "check.py": "01b4c9466e7800d0b019e30c84833b30d6f15cdcf89ec37ad4be21a65b726ed1",
    "input.json": "184ce01072015fbd43a2077a4b078e73404aca096be901c1fd39a5711d99cafd",
    "expected-primary.json": "90a9105b42ba256afea361e65db11655a21fe46bf81f69a967457cbe005290ae",
    "test_primary.py": "edefd8b10a23e41cc3688eef718e590f038848879237075dbee575d63ab5a22c",
    "provenance.json": "0c155d481acad393756a5b436a020b793cb60c553ec83b6682204f5bb9c3c1ed",
    "reproduce.py": "85c85c597aee81e611626034fe88bf482b883c92586dd4dba6ff9e00c7f6dcab",
    "reproduction.json": "2612d93a0e32e84c9d8d02a187392b83e0fad05904b90efda671c8597ee31c02",
    "independent/check-prefix.mjs": "48939caabdbb8dde57a5cf55180a8537ba91ae919d85f41a5c2c853886de4ddb",
    "independent/result.json": "4054a567dbacf6b7613b94c3d3c6a52e127d5b273fe2946a11aeb217162172cd",
    "independent/README.md": "8a05f4fdca0f5a2e43e3c6f85a02202cec511554d68ee97d8bdf51d9f53edebe",
    "independent/SHA256SUMS": "96f700a6ccf470cc2584b62c84c481fb296447e0cab15c0b66c9d5e962d68ae9",
    "independent/execution.txt": "b1b969e8cfd019edad9b116920b385d119482e8852fb31d1bc985d0300c0a35c"
  },
  "content_scope": [
    "Universal claim restricted to positive starts whose trajectories reach 1",
    "One-halving odd map, before-step parity and first-hit minimality",
    "Manual verification of both complete trajectories and shared affine identity",
    "Lagarias v13 PDF pages 1–2 checked for map and total stopping time",
    "Scope, prior-art and reproduction wording checked; no novelty conclusion"
  ],
  "code_scope": [
    "Exact integer arithmetic and strict primary input validation",
    "Step/value limits and incomplete-run UNKNOWN behavior",
    "Two wrong-map mutations in the primary tests",
    "Second program transition, first-hit and affine-identity certificate validation",
    "Thirteen deliberately corrupted certificates rejected by the second program",
    "Output equality and semantic comparison executed"
  ],
  "construction_provenance": "The second program was separately commissioned from the definitions without access to the primary checker. After its source and output were fixed, the owner inspected and compared both. This describes the authoring process; code inspection alone cannot prove construction independence.",
  "limitations": [
    "AI-assisted work in the same campaign; not external, human or formal verification",
    "No proof that either checker is defect-free",
    "No general Collatz, asymptotic, sampling-law or novelty conclusion",
    "Review is specific to the file hashes above; it does not upgrade legacy articles or graph claims"
  ]
}
