Aliquot sequences: trajectories are not density theorems
Working notebook synthesis, not a publication-reviewed article. Quotes reproduce recorded AI reviews; their status and scope are not independent verification.
The aliquot map s(n) sums the positive proper divisors of n. Iterating it produces a trajectory. A fiber asks which inputs reach a value; a density statement asks how common a set of inputs is. Neither a finite trajectory nor a sparse-fiber estimate by itself decides the ultimate fate of every orbit.
Evidence and reproduction status
This guide summarizes existing public notebook material. It establishes no new original result. Source statements, reported finite checks and in-campaign reviews have different roles; AI agreement is not mathematical validation. The underlying computational checks have not been rerun for this guide. Private artifacts are not exposed; a recorded evidence reference is not a public reproduction package.
Why the quantifiers matter
The notes distinguish an existential modification from a universal assertion and retain the remaining density obligation after a horizon reduction. A separate correction withdraws a pointwise assertion tied to the quasiperfect equation. These are repairs to the argument’s scope, not a termination theorem.
Source context: The first function and its iterates (preprint aliquot8, homepage-linked) — https://math.dartmouth.edu/~carlp/aliquot8.pdf.
Recorded AI review: Aliquot horizon quantifier
Existential modification equivalence verified; universal sufficiency fails. The T6 construction attains exactly Z_k. Horizon4 reduction uses Pollack Theorem1.11, not a proof that the remaining density vanishes.
Open exact review in notebook · review:aliquot-horizon-quantifier-0010
Recorded AI review: Aliquot quasiperfect counterexample repair
Withdraw the unproved pointwise claim D1(n+1)=N: equality is the quasiperfect equation. Use T=s+1 for pointwise total disagreement. Original n+1 density argument may be salvaged separately.
Open exact review in notebook · review:aliquot-quasiperfect-counterexample-repair-0010
A finite overlap tests a definition
The recorded example 52 checks a proposed disjointness claim under the stated membership condition on U. A single overlap can refute that claim. It cannot establish how frequent such examples are.
Recorded AI review: Aliquot52 overlap
52 is untouchable by complete exact check through2601 and has a9-step terminating trajectory; if included in U, it disproves disjointness of Z9 and U.
Open exact review in notebook · review:aliquot52-overlap-0010
What the sparse-fiber input supports
The note reports an upper-density bound of one half for seeds whose second iterate is prime, using a uniform sparse-fiber theorem and parity. The cited paper separates its small-set preimage theorem from broader conjectures. The recorded deduction is not zero density and says nothing here about ultimate fate.
Source context: Divisor-sum fibers (arXiv v1) — https://arxiv.org/pdf/1706.03120.
Recorded AI review: Aliquot prime second iterate half
Upper density of seeds whose second aliquot iterate is prime is at most1/2; deduction checked from PPT uniform sparse-fiber theorem and parity. No zero-density or fate conclusion.
Open exact review in notebook · review:aliquot-prime-second-iterate-half-0010
Why the evidence matters
These directed relationships restate scoped AI review claims. Each link shows its current evidence state; an absent link does not establish that no relationship exists.