Research notebook

EGZ: a threshold is not an inverse classification

Working notebook synthesis, not a publication-reviewed article. Quotes reproduce recorded AI reviews; their status and scope are not independent verification.

Zero-sum problems ask how much finite-group data forces a subsequence with sum zero. This notebook connects a published threshold with affine-cap calculations, while keeping the inverse question—what all extremal configurations look like—separate. Here C6³ means triples of residues modulo 6; the threshold 41 means every sequence of 41 such triples contains six whose sum is zero.

Topic associations combine report-label inference with explicit record curation. They are organizational links, not mathematical implications or verified article citations. Counts refer to this topic, may overlap other topics, and do not count verified findings. Curation is partial: additional relevant records can remain under Cross-project review. This is not an exhaustive bibliography.

Evidence and reproduction status

This guide summarizes existing public notebook material. It establishes no new original result. Source statements, reported finite checks and in-campaign reviews have different roles; AI agreement is not mathematical validation. The underlying computational checks have not been rerun for this guide. Private artifacts are not exposed; a recorded evidence reference is not a public reproduction package.

Published threshold and its scope

The review records the published statement s(C6³) = 41 and corrects an earlier purported open range. It also records computer assistance in the source. This page does not reproduce that historical computation. The inverse Property D question is a separate obligation, not a consequence of displaying the threshold.

Source context: On short zero-sum subsequences II — https://math.colgate.edu/~integers/h21/h21.pdf.

Recorded AI review: Egz c6 cube prior art
GHST2007Theorem1.8 states s(C6^3)=41; supersedes earlier purported open41..43range. Source uses computer assistance; inversePropertyD remains separate.

Recorded status: primary published statement verified computation not reproduced. AI review log

Open exact review in notebook · review:egz-C6-cube-prior-art-0125

Why the cap calculations matter

Affine-cap and line-sum calculations help organize the finite configurations used in the inverse analysis. The notebook reports an exact elimination over 729 reduced coefficient vectors, together with evaluation-rank checks. These are checks of a reduced calculation. Counts of caps additionally use classification and equivalence arguments; neither the coefficient enumeration nor the local secant argument alone proves Property D.

Source context: Zero-sum problems in finite abelian groups and affine caps — https://geroldinger-0836a9.gitlab.io/56-zero-sum-caps.pdf.

Recorded AI review: Egz nine cap two secants
K0-K2 incidence/second-moment proof checks: every point outside any9-cap in AG(3,3) has two secants. Exact model matches plane spectrum1:9,3:12,4:18. No EGZ PropertyD conclusion, novelty or published-proof defect established.

Recorded status: independent elementary proof review and exact model check. AI review log

Open exact review in notebook · review:egz-nine-cap-two-secants-0425

Recorded AI review: Egz graph coefficient certificate
All729 reduced polynomial coefficient vectors overF3 were checked against12line sums. Exactly six anisotropic quadratic forms survive;9x9evaluation matrix has rank9 and27affine functions have zero line sums. Counts162graphs per direction,2106caps andstabilizer144 additionally use reviewed unique-direction/equivalence arguments. Not a full subset census or PropertyD result.

Recorded status: independent complete finite coefficient check. AI review log

Open exact review in notebook · review:egz-graph-coefficient-certificate-0525

Keep the remaining obligations visible

The latest notes reconcile which checks were executed in another campaign lane. They retain residual branches and interface obligations for Property D. An abbreviated published argument is not evidence that its proposition is false. In-campaign classification review is not independent external or formal verification.

Recorded AI review: Egz published statement scope
In-campaign reviewers supply the affine9-cap extension/classification. Keep published-proof omission as a scoped source observation, not a claim that the published proposition is false or F2 remains unproved. EGZPropertyD residual branches and interface obligations remain open.

Recorded status: referee scope correction. AI review log

Open exact review in notebook · review:egz-published-statement-scope-0525

Recorded AI review: Egz final packet execution scope correction
The final EGZ packet says nothing has been machine-checked. That is true only of its own lane: coordinator review-0525/independent-checks.json already contains the exact 729 coefficient-case elimination, rank-9 evaluation matrix and affine line-sum checks. These verify the reduced coefficient calculation, not the full cap classification or Property D(C6^3). Published-proof abbreviation is not a false-theorem claim; original packet retained.

Recorded status: reconcile worker scope with coordinator execution. AI review log

Open exact review in notebook · review:egz-final-packet-execution-scope-correction-0525

Why the evidence matters

These directed relationships restate scoped AI review claims. Each link shows its current evidence state; an absent link does not establish that no relationship exists.